#2 on the 2024 Bacon Top 31 — Waxahatchee

January 30, 2025 by Royal Stuart in Top 31, 2024

Tigers Blood by Waxahatchee

It is surprisingly difficult to reread my review of Waxahatchee’s last album, Saint Cloud, my #1 album of 2020. That album came out March 27 that year, just as the world was locking down. This was the first year of Covid, with (only) 400,000 deaths. Saint Cloud was the blanket that kept us warm, the unexpectedly bright star in that darkness. 2024 wasn’t nearly as dark, as Covid is mostly controlled, having left the world scarred and scared. And here as I write this at the end of January 2025, we’re in a different kind of dark times, unsure where the world is headed. “Unsettled,” as a vibe.

We’re so lucky to have Katie Crutchfield and her band to help prop us up and give us the energy we need to carry on. Like Katie to her sister Alison, Tigers Blood is very much a twin to Saint Cloud. Crutchfield brought back Brad Cook to produce the album (he also plays bass on every song aside from one). His ability to bring the coziness of the recording space into these songs is impeccable as always. You could easily play both albums back to back and have no real indication where one album ends and the other begins, aside from one notable exception: the backing vocals of one MJ Lenderman.

You may recall Lenderman, whose recent solo album was featured at #9 this year. His dry drawl is a perfect lower-register match to Crutchfield’s strong twang. Lenderman’s guitar appears across every song on the album, and he provides exquisite harmonies on four of them, often singing an unexpected harmonic tone underneath but not hidden from the forefront. The first single from the album, “Right Back To It” has Lenderman’s voice so prominent that he received a “ft. MJ Lenderman” credit in the song title. Released just over two months before the album came out, it was a strong indication of where Waxahatchee was headed.

Another highlight of Lenderman’s backing vocals is the “title song,” a slow, depressing-in-a-good-way dirge that ends with the entire band lending their voices to the chorus. I challenge you to zone in on Lenderman’s voice when you can pick it up underneath Crutchfield. The choices he makes for the harmony line are entirely unique and surprising. It makes me want to go back and give his band Wednesday’s 2023 album Rat Saw God another proper listen.

The highlight for me on the album is also the most sparse, “365.” I first truly fell for Waxahatchee on her song “Chapel of Pines” from the 2018 EP Great Thunder. It’s a simple song, just an acoustic guitar and Crutchfield’s strong, dripping-with-emotion voice planted firmly in your ear. This is where Waxahatchee shines brightest, when she is at her most intimate. “365” is similar in tone – simple acoustic baritone guitar from Brad Cook, organ from his brother Phil, Lenderman on a second acoustic guitar, and drummer (and Jeff Tweedy’s son) Spencer Tweedy playing a lone cymbal, everything drawn back to let Crutchfield’s voice proceed unhindered. The song is a gut punch, describing a person whose whole being is wrapped up in their broken-beyond-repair partner:

“I catch your poison arrow. I catch your same disease. Bow like a weeping willow, buc-kle-in’ at the knees, beg-gin’ you ‘please.’ If you fly up beyond the cosmos, it’s a long way to fall back down. Ya always go ’bout this the wrong way, and I’m too weak to just let you drown. So when you kill, I kill, When you ache, I ache. We both haunt this ol’ lifeless town When you fail, I fail When you fly, I fly, And it’s a long way to come back down.”

Crutchfield’s own voice doubles up her lead vocals, going up even higher on the verse above. It is such an unbelievably wrenching baring of emotion, you can feel throughout your entire being this person’s anguish at being stuck in this situation.

There is not a bad song on Tigers Blood. You can watch videos for the much more amped up and rocking “Bored,” evoking sounds of Rilo Kiley¹, and the more traditional slow country “Much Ado About Nothing.” Better yet, you should watch Waxahatchee’s latest “NPR Tiny Desk Concert” from December, 2024. This is their third appearance in the series, having appeared back in 2013, young, solo on guitar, and rough around the edges, and again with a special “Tiny Desk (Home) Concert” in April 2020, with her boyfriend Kevin Morby (another Top 31 alum – #3 in 2022²).

Waxahatchee has been on a massive wave since I started following them shortly after the release of their 2018 EP. The audience keeps getting bigger, and Crutchfield’s reach keeps getting wider. This year she’s been nominated for a Grammy, for best Americana album. The category is full of names I don’t recognize, aside from the heavy hitter T. Bone Burnett, who I imagine would be a lock with the Grammy voters. But maybe we’ll be able to see Katie sharing that stage with Beyoncé or Taylor Swift or Kendrick Lamar on February 2. If not, I’m fairly certain this won’t be her only opportunity. Here’s to looking forward to the next one!

^{1. I’ve learned today that Rilo Kiley, led by Top 31 alum Jenny Lewis (#24 in 2014) is reuniting and touring this summer – I’m going to assume Waxahatchee leading the currently indie rock scene into alt.country heaven is what has made that happen.↩}
^{2. Crutchfield showed up in 2022 as well, as half of the duo Plains with Jess Williamson on their fantastic I Walked With You a Ways at #13.↩}

__________________________________________

Subscribe to the Top 31 playlists!

Full Albums
All albums in their entirety

Radio Station
The best song pulled from each album

View all previous years’ Top 31s

#22 on the 2023 Bacon Top 31 — Ratboys

January 10, 2024 by Royal Stuart in Top 31

The Window by Ratboys

There seem to have been a slew of artists on the 2023 Top 31 who have been writing, performing, and producing music for over a decade before finally hitting my radar and/or making something great enough to beat out the competition. Please add Chicago’s Ratboys to that list. The band formed back in 2010 when their lead singer, Julia Steiner, and guitarist David Sagan were going to Notre Dame. They released their debut album, AOID, in 2015. Four albums later, here we are with their fantastic fifth full-length, The Window.

I haven’t yet compared Ratboys’ The Window against their previous work, but I feel safe in saying there’s a reason their new album has risen above the fray to land here on the Top 31, and that reason goes by the name Chris Walla. You may know Walla as a huge part of the formation and longevity of Death Cab for Cutie. He left DCFC in 2014 after 17 years, but has continued producing other band’s work to great success, including The Long Winters, The Decemberists, and Tegan and Sara.

Ratboys has a little more fuzz in their twang, but they remind me of a number of past Top 31 alt-country artists. Steiner’s vocals most closely resemble Jenny Lewis (#24 in 2014). There’s a little Big Thief (2017, 2019, and last year), and some definite Katie Crutchfield in there (aka Waxahatchee, whose Saint Cloud was #1 in 2020). If you’ve liked any of those bands, then The Window is for you.

Still having doubts? Then check out the band’s unbelievably good live set they performed at KEXP back in October. I only just watched it for the first time today, a couple days after I wrote the rest of this review, and just one day before this review is published (thanks Pete for pointing it out to me!), and now I’m wondering if I’ve ranked this album too low on the Top 31. That extended guitar solo in the middle of “Black Earth, WI” is Doug Martsch-esque. It‘s too late now to change it, but mark my words: when Ratboys’ next album is in the Top 10 for the year it comes out, I’ll come back here and read this review and remember exactly why it’s at #22.

__________________________________________

Subscribe to the Top 31 playlists!

Full Albums
All albums in their entirety

Radio Station
The best song pulled from each album

View all previous years’ Top 31s

#3 on the 2021 Bacon Top 31 — Japanese Breakfast

January 29, 2022 by Royal Stuart in Top 31

Jubilee by Japanese Breakfast

Despite striving myself on my punctuality, I’m often late to the party. Japanese Breakfast, a band of indefinite size and location fronted by Korean-born, Oregon-raised renaissance woman Michelle Zauner, is a prime example. Their album, Jubilee, that I have so valiantly placed at #3 on my Top 31 for the entirety of 2021, did not enter my audio purview until December 28, 2021. If I’d posted my Top 31 in December, as I used to do until a few years ago, this album would have not been included at all.

Instead, I learned about it thanks to the fantastic KEXP community, who voted this phenomenal third album from the band as their #1 album of the year. I didn’t even hear the live broadcast of that announcement. I read about it a few days later, decided to listen to the album that had struck everyone’s fancy, and was subsequently left trying to figure out how to pick up the pieces of my exploded brain that had scattered around the living room.

This is pop music in its purest, most exciting form. Zauner’s wit, song structure, and bubbly voice – equal parts Grimes and Jenny Lewis – weave a tapestry of pure joy for ten solid songs. The peak of the joy comes at song #2, “Be Sweet,” featured in the video shown above. That chorus – “Be sweet to me baby. I want to believe in you, I want to belieeeeeeve” – is so sickly sweet, I die.

The last song on the album, “Posing for Cars,” is the least pop-like song on the album, but the extended, Doug Martsch-esque guitar solo showcases Zauner’s skills on the instrument. And skilled she is. In addition to having penned three albums with Japanese Breakfast, Zauner is also the director for nearly all of their music videos. And these aren’t some cheap band-performance videos. They’re full-on stories, sometimes strung together into epics. The other two videos from Jubilee are “Posing in Bondage” and “Savage Good Boy,” featuring Micheal Imperioli (best known as Christopher Moltisanti from the Sopranos), and is meant to be a prequel to the story shown in “Bondage.” Zauner has also directed videos for Better Oblivion Community Center, Charly Bliss, and Jay Som.

As if that weren’t enough, she released her first book in 2021. Crying in H Mart: A Memoir debuted at #2 on the NYTimes Best Seller List in April. And it’s now being adapted into a film by Orion Pictures, of which the soundtrack will be supplied by Japanese Breakfast.

Jubilee has been nominated for Best Alternative Music Album, and the band for Best New Artist Grammys (not sure how that works, given that this album is their third as a band). Pitchfork, in their 7.8/10 review of Jubilee, declared 2021 as “Jbrekkie Season,” and I have to agree. This doesn’t feel like the top – this feels like we’re only at the beginning of something huge, like, the birth of a new Michelangelo. I absolutely cannot wait to see what comes next.

__________________________________________

4. A Way Forward by Nation of Language
5. Things Take Time, Take Time by Courtney Barnett
6. Little Oblivions by Julien Baker
7. Valentine by Snail Mail
8. sketchy. by tUnE-yArDs
9. A Very Lonely Solstice by Fleet Foxes
10. Hey What by Low
11. Local Valley by José González
12. Head of Roses by Flock of Dimes
13. The Nearer the Fountain, More Pure the Stream Flows by Damon Albarn
14. Collapsed in Sunbeams by Arlo Parks
15. Loving In Stereo by Jungle
16. Flying Dream 1 by Elbow
17. Screen Violence by Chvrches
18. Blue Weekend by Wolf Alice
19. Mainly Gestalt Pornography by Pearly Gate Music
20. Peace Or Love by Kings of Convenience
21. These 13 by Jimbo Mathus & Andrew Bird
22. Mr. Corman: Season 1 by Nathan Johnson
23. Home Video by Lucy Dacus
24. I’ll Be Your Mirror: A Tribute to The Velvet Underground & Nico by Various Artists
25. Siamese Dream by Fruit Bats
26. NINE by Sault
27. Observatory by Aeon Station
28. The Monster Who Hated Pennsylvania by Damien Jurado
29. A Beginner’s Mind by Sufjan Stevens and Angelo De Augustine
30. Where the End Begins by Knathan Ryan
31. Private Space by Durand Jones & The Indications

There are many ways to listen to the 2021 Bacon Top 31. Subscribe now and enjoy the new albums / songs as the countdown is completed!

Full Album
All albums in their entirety.

Radio Station
A single song selection pulled from each album.

View all previous Bacon Top 31s

#24 on the 2014 Bacon Top 31

December 08, 2014 by Royal Stuart

The Voyager by Jenny Lewis

I’ve been a fan of the artist at #24 for a very long time. First as the lead singer of the pop rock group Rilo Kiley, and then through various solo releases, Jenny Lewis has kept my attention rapt for over ten years now. The Voyager is Lewis’s third solo release. Her first solo release, 2006’s Rabbit Fur Coat, found Lewis performing with the Watson Twins to create a beautiful countrified version of what Lewis was making popular with her former band. Her second solo album, Acid Tongue, fell flat for me.

But this new album felt different. It’s certainly hit or miss — there are some stellar rock & roll pop hits on here, mixed with lackluster songs of longing and jealousy. But overall, it’s a good record of where Lewis finds herself today, with many personal triumphs and feelings shared for us all.

My favorite song on the album is the title song, which comes at the end of the record. Orchestral, slow, and harkening back to the country songs she wrote for her first solo album, the song meanders across drug references, space travel references, loose ties to religion and many other areas, explaining nothing and everything at once.

The song featured in the video above is also a standout on the album. I wrote about this particular video back in July when it came out:

“Just One of the Guys” is a fantastic send-up of gender and parenthood roles in the music business and beyond. Helping Lewis convey this fact are Anne Hathaway, Kristen Stewart, Brie Larson and drummer Tennessee Thomas, sometimes dressed in drag. Listen to the words of this one. Joking nature aside, there are some very poignant things being said within.

And there’s a lot more biting commentary just like that across the album. Get it now and experience it for yourself.

__________________________________________

25. Voices by Phantogram
26. Morning Phase by Beck
27. Hungry Ghosts by OK Go
28. Run the Jewels 2 by Run the Jewels
29. Cosmos by Yellow Ostrich
30. Teeth Dreams by The Hold Steady
31. With Light & With Love by Woods

2009-2013 Top 31s

Jenny Lewis — Just One of the Guys

July 17, 2014 by Royal Stuart

And now for some more fun. Jenny Lewis has been doing her own thing for quite a while (since Rilo Kiley broke up for good in 2011, with their last recorded work coming out all the way back in 2007). Lewis’s third solo album, The Voyager, comes out July 29, 2014. The video above, for the first song released from the album, “Just One of the Guys,” is a fantastic send-up of gender and parenthood roles in the music business and beyond.

Helping Lewis convey this fact are Anne Hathaway, Kristen Stewart, Brie Larson and drummer Tennessee Thomas, sometimes dressed in drag. Listen to the words of this one. Joking nature aside, there are some very poignant things being said within. I can’t wait for more.

Rilo Kiley — Emotional

November 28, 2013 by Royal Stuart

Jenny Lewis’s former band has gotten better since they broke up. This song, “Emotional,” with its awesomely drawn out chorus “You’re so E-MO-TION-AL” and its guitar solo outro, is a perfect little pop rock song. I have yet to pick up the album of rarities the band released this year, from which this song is from — RKives — but I just convinced myself that that’s going to have to change.